The Recliner Dilemma: Finding Middle Ground Between Comfort and Aesthetics

As an interior designer, I’ve had countless conversations with clients about the age-old debate of recliners in the home. The husband usually wants the big, cozy recliner plopped right in front of the TV, while the wife would prefer something a little more, well, stylish. I completely understand both sides of the argument – comfort is key, but we also want our living spaces to look magazine-worthy, right?

I’ll admit, I used to be firmly in the anti-recliner camp. Those oversized, puffy monstrosities from the 70s and 80s just made me cringe. They seemed to dominate the room, forcing all the other furniture to the edges like timid wallflowers at a dance. But over the years, I’ve learned that there is a happy medium to be found. With a little creativity and an open mind, you can absolutely incorporate a recliner into your living space without sacrificing style or comfort.

Reimagining the Recliner

The key, I’ve found, is to “reimagine” the traditional recliner. Canadian designer Meredith Heron is a pro at this. She firmly believes that recliners can work in any space, as long as they don’t look like recliners. In one of her designs, Heron took the classic leather recliner and transformed it into a pair of sleek, velvet club chairs that seamlessly blend into the pale gray and cream color palette.

Meredith Heron’s custom recliner design

Similarly, the team at Tomar Lampert Associates created a pair of channel-back recliners in a serene shade that serve as the focal point in a monochromatic room. These custom-upholstered beauties look more like cozy armchairs than bulky recliners.

Tomar Lampert Associates’ custom recliner design

The takeaway here is that if your budget allows, a custom-upholstered recliner is the way to go. It allows you to maintain all the creature comforts without compromising the style of your space.

Scaling It Down

Of course, custom-made furniture isn’t always an option, especially for those of us on a budget. Luckily, retailers have started to pay attention to the demand for more streamlined, modern recliner options.

One example that caught my eye is the Milo Baughman Recliner 74 from Design Within Reach. The walnut legs elevate the body of the chair, making it feel much less bulky than its traditional counterparts. And the wispy arms, along with the elongated back, create a frame that is more ballerina than lumbering lumberjack. The overall sense of lightness and airiness ensures this recliner won’t overwhelm the room.

Milo Baughman Recliner 74 from Design Within Reach

For those who prefer a more transitional take on the recliner, the Juno Recliner from Room and Board is a great option. The modified wing chair style makes it a perfect fit for both traditional and contemporary spaces. And when the chair is in the fully reclined position, it takes up minimal extra space, so you don’t need a runway to fully enjoy its comfort.

Juno Recliner from Room and Board

The key takeaway here is that, just like any other piece of furniture, a recliner needs to be in scale with the rest of the room. A recliner that’s too big can throw off the entire design and flow of the space.

Forget It (or Find an Alternative)

Of course, there are times when a recliner just won’t work, no matter how hard you try. Maybe it’s a matter of floor space, budget constraints, or the fear of causing a marital dispute (you know, the little things). In cases like these, I suggest looking for alternative solutions that can still provide the comfort you’re craving.

One option is to go with a lounge chair and ottoman combo, as seen in this room from the portfolio of architectural photographer David Churchill. This setup allows the homeowner to put their feet up, just like with a recliner, but it also provides additional seating in a pinch – something a recliner can’t offer. And from a design standpoint, I love that the designer chose to inject a different chair silhouette into the room, rather than mirroring the boxiness of the club chair in the corner.

Lounge chair and ottoman from David Churchill’s portfolio

Another alternative is to ditch the chair altogether and go for a chaise lounge. As demonstrated in this design by Gardner Mohr Architects, a chaise can serve as a beautiful focal point in a room while still providing that sought-after comfort and relaxation. I can easily envision the clients curling up with a magazine and a glass of wine on that stunning cowhide chaise.

Chaise lounge from Gardner Mohr Architects’ design

So while I may never be a cheerleader for recliners, I am a huge proponent of creating spaces that are both comfortable and livable. Your home should be a reflection of how you use the space, but remember that a recliner isn’t the only way to enjoy the luxury of propping your feet up at the end of a long day.

Finding the Right Balance

Look, I get it – oversized recliners aren’t exactly a favorite among many designers. But the fact is, a lot of people remain loyal fans of them for pure comfort. The key is to find a stylish, modern option that doesn’t scream “1970s living room.”

Sofa Spectacular has a great selection of tailored, leather recliners that would look right at home in a contemporary space. Paired with a sleek sofa and a few carefully curated accent pieces, these recliners can become a seamless part of the overall design.

And let’s not forget about the ever-popular sectional with a built-in chaise. This is a fantastic compromise that gives you the comfort of a recliner without the bulky, standalone piece. Plus, it provides ample seating for the whole family.

At the end of the day, it’s all about finding what works best for your lifestyle and your space. If a recliner is an absolute must-have, then embrace it! Just be strategic about the style and placement. And if recliners just aren’t your thing, no problem – there are plenty of other ways to achieve that same level of coziness and relaxation.

Remember, your home should be a reflection of your personal style and preferences, not anyone else’s. So don’t be afraid to break the rules and do what feels right for you. After all, the only opinion that truly matters is your own.